NOAA's Climate Prediction Center lowered its chance of a historic October to December from 83% to about 60% in the same month that Niño-3.4 rose from +2.1°C to +2.5°C. Both statements are in the discussion, and they answer different questions.
On 12 November, NOAA's Climate Prediction Center (CPC) lowered the probability that this El Niño reaches a “historic” peak, and in the same discussion reported that the event is still strengthening. For October to December, the chance of a three-month RONI at or above +2.5°C fell from 83% in the 8 October discussion to about 60%. For November to January it fell from 70% to about 60%. Between the two discussions, the monthly relative Niño-3.4 anomaly CPC quotes rose from +2.1°C (September) to +2.5°C (October).
| CPC item (relative index) | 8 Oct 2026 | 12 Nov 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Status | El Niño Advisory | El Niño Advisory |
| Niño-3.4 / Niño-3 / Niño-1+2, monthly relative, as quoted | +2.1 / +3.0 / +3.9°C | +2.5 / +3.6 / +4.4°C |
| Historic (RONI ≥ +2.5°C), OND | 83% | about 60% |
| Historic (RONI ≥ +2.5°C), NDJ | 70% | about 60% |
| Strong to very strong through JFM | greater than 83% | greater than 79% |
| Very strong (≥ +2.0°C), OND / NDJ | 100% / 96% | 100% / 96% |
| Very strong (≥ +2.0°C), DJF / JFM | 81% / 46% | 79% / 35% |
| Outlook wording | Continue to strengthen through the end of the year | Continue to strengthen, then begin to weaken in early 2027 |
The observations in the November discussion point toward a stronger event. Niño-3 rose from +3.0°C to +3.6°C and Niño-1+2 from +3.9°C to +4.4°C. CPC says sea surface temperature anomalies above +4.0°C now extend farther west along the equator, that the subsurface heat index is significantly above average, and that anomalies exceed +10°C at depth. Trade winds are weaker, convection is enhanced over the central and eastern Pacific, and the Southern Oscillation Index has been consistently negative.
The probability is a different object. A historic event is a three-month average RONI at or above +2.5°C, and the season still contains months that have not happened. The 60% is a forecast of that average. The Niño-3.4 value is a monthly reading of the ocean, not a three-month average: the quoted values are monthly relative anomalies (see the data vintage note). A reading can climb while the odds on a later average come down. The outlook sentence changed too: in October CPC expected El Niño to keep strengthening through the end of the year, and in November it says the event will keep strengthening before beginning to weaken in early 2027.
The OND historic odds have now run 69% in August, 75% in September, 83% in October and about 60% in November (see the August threshold analysis and the September update). For scale, the October to December record on this index is +2.25°C (1997) and the highest three-month value in any season is +2.40°C (DJF 1983), so +2.5°C is a high bar even for a strong event.
It matters which line is being crossed. CPC's “historic” wording refers to a three-month RONI at or above +2.5°C, above any value since 1950. “Very strong” is the top bin of CPC's strength table, an index at or above +2.0°C. They are separate cuts through the same forecast. Lowering the odds of the first does not necessarily lower the odds of the second.
On the table figures, it has not. For October to December and November to January, the chance of a very strong event is 100% and 96% in both the October and November tables. It slipped slightly later in the winter: December to February from 81% to 79%, and January to March from 46% to 35%. Our reading of the tables, not CPC's wording, is that the revision is not evidence that the observed event has weakened: a very strong El Niño remains near certain through the early winter, although the later-winter strength probabilities were lowered. For why “super” is not an official category, see our explainer, and for the index basis see RONI vs ONI.
The 12 November discussion does not give a reason for lowering the historic odds. We read it, the 8 October discussion and the strength and outlook tables, and none explains the change. We will not supply one. The conditions the text lists (weaker trades, deep subsurface heat, enhanced convection) are described as part of the event's strength and are not connected to the lower probability. The accurate statement is that the odds fell by about 23 points for OND and 10 for NDJ, with the cause unpublished in the material we read. CPC states “about 60%” for both seasons.
The core call is intact, though slightly lower: a strong to very strong El Niño is likely through January to March 2027, with CPC's stated chance now greater than 79% (it was greater than 83%). In the strength tables that figure matches the January to March strong (1.5 to below 2.0°C) and very strong cells added together: 37% plus 46% in October, 44% plus 35% in November. That sum is our check, not CPC's wording.
CPC expects the event to weaken after its winter peak: the November strength table gives neutral conditions a 75% chance in May to July. It adds that even with a very strong El Niño, El Niño-like impacts are more likely but not guaranteed. Other agencies' headline numbers are not CPC's, as the WMO comparison and the JMA Niño-3 record show, and NASA's sea-level maps add a separate view of the winter.
This piece makes no forecast of its own. It compares two CPC issuances.
Checkpoints: compare CPC's 10 December 2026 discussion and its probabilities, and the eventual October to December RONI value, with the 12 November issuance described here.