NOAA favors a warmer winter for Chicago and the Great Lakes, with fewer cold-air outbreaks and less lake ice. CPC’s seasonal outlook does not predict snowfall totals, and El Niño winters have still delivered big snow. Here is what the outlook says, what the record shows, and what to watch after CPC’s November 19 update.
On November 12, NOAA’s Climate Prediction Center (CPC) reported the Niño-3.4 index at +2.5°C, which rounds October’s monthly relative value of +2.47°C in CPC’s monthly file, and said a strong to very strong El Niño is likely through January to March 2027, with a probability greater than 79 percent. For Chicago the practical question is what that does to December through February. NOAA’s winter outlook, issued October 15, tilts the odds toward a warmer winter across the Great Lakes. It does not tilt them toward a snowless one.
Local coverage has run ahead of that. A Time Out Chicago headline on October 19 pointed to “the warmest Chicago winter of the century,” yet the article itself supports only “warmer than average” and gives no ranking. A CBS News Chicago piece last updated May 19 still carries May’s ENSO odds and says the three most recent very strong El Niño events left Chicago with less than half of its typical snowfall. NWS Chicago’s own tables do not show that, as the snow section below lays out.
CPC’s outlook issued October 15 favors above-normal temperatures across the northern tier, including the Midwest, with the highest odds over the Great Lakes, the upper Mississippi Valley and the interior Northeast. Chicago is not named. Reading CPC’s December to February map against its color legend, we place Chicago and northern Illinois in the 50 to 60 percent band for above-normal temperature, near its southern edge. That is our reading of a map, not a number CPC published for the city.
Precipitation is thinner. NOAA’s regional Great Lakes briefing (dated November 2026, listed on Drought.gov as November 5) describes two different things. For a typical El Niño winter it says the odds of dry conditions rise, especially in the southern part of the basin. For this winter it shows CPC’s outlook map, with a slightly increased chance of below-normal precipitation across the central Great Lakes and equal chances across the southern and eastern basin. A typical pattern and this winter’s outlook need not match, and the map is the one that applies. On CPC’s map, as we read it, Chicago sits in equal chances, with the below-normal area to the north and east.
| Question | What NOAA favors for Dec to Feb | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Temperature | Above normal favored. About 50 to 60 percent at Chicago (our reading of the map). | CPC outlook, Oct 15 |
| Precipitation | Equal chances at Chicago (our reading). Slight tilt to below normal over the central and northern lakes. | CPC outlook, Oct 15; NOAA Great Lakes briefing |
| Cold-air outbreaks | Tend to be less frequent. Cold weather still occurs. | NOAA Great Lakes briefing |
| Snowfall | CPC’s seasonal outlook does not predict snowfall totals. NOAA says it “does not project seasonal snowfall accumulations.” | NOAA release, Oct 15 |
A seasonal precipitation outlook ranks the three-month total of liquid water against normal. It does not say whether that water falls as snow, sleet or rain, how many storms deliver it, or how much arrives in a day. Snow depends on a storm’s track, temperature profile and timing, and NOAA says it is generally not predictable more than about a week ahead. Associated Press reported on October 16 that NWS meteorologists expect below-normal snow across the Great Lakes. That is a forecaster’s judgment, not a number in CPC’s seasonal outlook, which does not predict snowfall totals.
The same logic explains why warmth does not rule out a major snowstorm. A temperature outlook describes the average of about 90 days, and a winter can finish warm while still holding the few cold days a big storm needs. NOAA’s Great Lakes briefing says El Niño is not known to change the track or intensity of any single weather system or the potential for ice storms and blizzards. NWS Cleveland adds that a warmer winter “will not translate to ‘never cold’.”
NWS Chicago’s seasonal table (July to June, 1950-51 to 2021-22) lists 72 seasons from 19.8 to 89.7 inches against a stated normal of 38.4. Winters are classed by their November to January (NDJ) value of CPC’s Relative Oceanic Niño Index, with El Niño at +0.5 or above and weak, moderate, strong and very strong starting at +0.5, +1.0, +1.5 and +2.0. Every winter’s value and snowfall is listed under the table.
| NDJ RONI band | Winters | Median snowfall (in) | Below 38.4-in normal | Range (in) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Very strong (+2.0 or more) | 3 | 29.6 | 3 of 3 | 26.6 to 31.2 |
| Strong (+1.5 to +1.99) | 5 | 28.4 | 4 of 5 | 20.0 to 54.2 |
| Moderate (+1.0 to +1.49) | 7 | 29.4 | 5 of 7 | 24.1 to 82.3 |
| Weak (+0.5 to +0.99) | 10 | 42.9 | 1 of 10 | 35.6 to 77.0 |
| All El Niño winters in the table | 25 | 35.6 | 13 of 25 | 20.0 to 82.3 |
| All other winters (La Niña and neutral) | 47 | 39.2 | 22 of 47 | 19.8 to 89.7 |
| Winter (NDJ) | NDJ RONI | Band | July to June snowfall (in) | vs 38.4-in normal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1951-52 | +0.71 | Weak | 66.4 | above |
| 1953-54 | +0.66 | Weak | 43.2 | above |
| 1957-58 | +1.75 | Strong | 20.0 | below |
| 1958-59 | +0.64 | Weak | 41.0 | above |
| 1963-64 | +1.07 | Moderate | 35.2 | below |
| 1965-66 | +1.81 | Strong | 24.9 | below |
| 1968-69 | +1.02 | Moderate | 29.4 | below |
| 1969-70 | +0.68 | Weak | 77.0 | above |
| 1972-73 | +1.88 | Strong | 32.9 | below |
| 1976-77 | +1.08 | Moderate | 54.1 | above |
| 1977-78 | +1.05 | Moderate | 82.3 | above |
| 1979-80 | +0.64 | Weak | 42.4 | above |
| 1982-83 | +2.36 | Very strong | 26.6 | below |
| 1986-87 | +1.42 | Moderate | 26.2 | below |
| 1987-88 | +0.80 | Weak | 42.6 | above |
| 1991-92 | +1.97 | Strong | 28.4 | below |
| 1994-95 | +1.28 | Moderate | 24.1 | below |
| 1997-98 | +2.28 | Very strong | 29.6 | below |
| 2002-03 | +1.13 | Moderate | 28.6 | below |
| 2004-05 | +0.69 | Weak | 39.4 | above |
| 2006-07 | +0.89 | Weak | 35.6 | below |
| 2009-10 | +1.50 | Strong | 54.2 | above |
| 2014-15 | +0.62 | Weak | 50.7 | above |
| 2015-16 | +2.25 | Very strong | 31.2 | below |
| 2018-19 | +0.78 | Weak | 49.5 | above |
| 2023-24 | +1.40 | Moderate | not in table | n/a |
RONI: CPC RONI.ascii.txt, row NDJ for the first year, as served 16 November 2026. Snowfall: NWS Chicago seasonal table, July to June. 2023-24 is not in the NWS table.
Moderate or stronger El Niño winters show the clearest lean: 12 of 15 finished below normal, and 7 of the 8 strong and very strong winters did, with a median of 29.0 inches. Weak events point the other way, with 9 of 10 at or above normal. The exceptions matter as much as the rule: the strong event of 2009-10 produced 54.2 inches, and the moderate event of 1977-78 produced 82.3, the second most of the 72 seasons. Three of the ten snowiest seasons since 1950-51 were El Niño winters. Only three very strong winters exist in the record, and this event may exceed all of them, so the table is context and not a forecast.
On the CBS claim, the three most recent very strong winters (1982-83, 1997-98 and 2015-16) had December to February snowfall of 16.0, 18.1 and 16.3 inches in NWS Chicago’s winter table, which is 54 to 61 percent of the 29.6-inch normal. That is a large shortfall and still not “less than half.” CBS may use a different station or period, and its article labels no source for the figure. The temperature half is plausible: the Illinois State Climatologist put statewide December to February 5.6°F above average in 1997-98 and 4.6°F in 1982-83, with snowfall much below average. On storms, only one of the five on NWS Chicago’s top-ten list since 1950 came in an El Niño winter (14.3 inches in March 1970, a weak event). The four largest, in 1967, 1979, 1999 and 2011, did not.
The NWS lake-effect explainer describes cold air moving across the relatively warm, unfrozen water of the Great Lakes: warmth and moisture rise into the air and form clouds that can organize into narrow bands producing 2 to 3 inches of snow per hour or more, and wind direction is a key factor in which areas get it. Warmer, open water can support heavier lake-effect snow when other conditions cooperate, but a bigger temperature contrast or a longer stretch of water does not by itself guarantee more snow. Ice cover suppresses the exchange of heat and moisture between the lake and the air, so it cuts the supply rather than switching it off everywhere at once. That leaves three things to track: how warm the water is, how much of it is open, and how often cold air arrives.
The water is warm. NWS Cleveland’s freeze-up outlook, issued November 5, reports October temperatures 3 to 7°F above normal across the region and early-November surface water temperatures 4 to 8°F above normal. Harbor readings that day:
| Harbor | Nov 5, 2026 | Normal | Departure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Duluth | 55°F | 44°F | +11°F |
| Sault Ste. Marie | 54°F | 47°F | +7°F |
| Chicago | 58°F | 53°F | +5°F |
| Alpena | 55°F | 48°F | +7°F |
| Detroit | 58°F | 52°F | +6°F |
| Cleveland | 62°F | 56°F | +6°F |
| Buffalo | 58°F | 54°F | +4°F |
Harbor departures are larger than open-lake ones, and open water is what feeds lake-effect snow. The same outlook’s ten mid-lake readings ran between 1°F below and 3°F above normal, and Lake Michigan’s southern reading was 57°F against a normal of 56°F. The lakes are warm, but the open-water surplus is smaller than the harbor numbers suggest.
NWS Cleveland expects below-average ice cover for 2026-27 and no ice formation in November. It ties ice to the heat the water stored over summer and how fast Arctic outbreaks and wind remove it. NOAA’s briefing likewise says a warmer winter may reduce basin-wide ice cover.
The two halves of the El Niño story pull in opposite directions here. Fewer cold-air outbreaks mean fewer chances for lake-effect snow, while warm, open lakes can make each outbreak that does arrive more productive when the other ingredients line up. NWS Cleveland states only the second half, and conditionally: if the lakes stay open, more numerous lake-effect events become possible. NOAA’s briefing does not mention lake-effect snow, and no source we read says which effect wins.
For Chicago itself the lake matters in a narrower way. Chicago sits on Lake Michigan’s western shore, so in a northwesterly outbreak it is upwind of the water and the heaviest lake-effect snow falls on the far shore. Chicago gets lake-enhanced snow mainly when winds blow off the lake, from the north to northeast.
Across the basin the picture has the same shape with different edges. NOAA and CPC favor above-normal temperatures, with the highest odds over the Great Lakes, and Associated Press coverage named Wisconsin and Michigan among the drier areas. NOAA’s briefing shows below-average January to March snowfall across the Great Lakes in past moderate-to-strong El Niño winters (1959 to 2023), as a tendency and not a rule, and notes that a long-term warming trend makes the El Niño signal harder to isolate. Its ENSO odds (83 percent for the strongest event on record, 100 percent for El Niño lasting into early 2027) carry no issue date and do not match CPC’s November 12 update, so this post uses the November 12 numbers.
It does not show that Chicago will have a below-normal snow year, a warm December or a particular lake-effect outcome. It includes no current reading of the Arctic Oscillation or the stratospheric polar vortex, which can bring colder stretches that an El Niño outlook leaves out; our November 2 post covers a possible disruption.
Our reading. For Chicago the official signal is a warm tilt and little else: precipitation is near equal chances and CPC predicts no snowfall totals. For the basin, warm open lakes and fewer cold outbreaks work against each other, and nothing published yet says which wins. This is a lean, not a promise. CPC’s November 19 update does not name Chicago, and NWS Cleveland’s pending freeze-up update is the next lake reading to look for.
The record tilts that way but does not promise it. In NWS Chicago's seasonal table, 12 of 15 winters with a moderate, strong or very strong El Niño (by NDJ RONI) finished below the 38.4-inch normal. Three did not, including 2009-10 at 54.2 inches. CPC's seasonal outlook does not predict snowfall totals.
No. A temperature outlook describes the three-month average, and NOAA says El Niño is not known to change the track or intensity of any single weather system or the potential for blizzards. A warm winter can still contain the cold days a major snowstorm needs.
NOAA does not say. Fewer cold-air outbreaks mean fewer chances, while warm, open lakes can make an outbreak more productive when the other ingredients line up. NWS Cleveland says only that if the lakes stay open, more numerous lake-effect events become possible.
CPC issued new seasonal outlooks on Thursday, November 19; the update note at the top of this post summarizes what its discussion says about the Great Lakes. NWS Cleveland's freeze-up update, due about two weeks after its November 5 outlook, had not appeared when we checked on November 20. Watch open-lake temperatures, ice cover, the Arctic Oscillation and CPC's December 10 ENSO discussion.