California recorded its first sea turtle nests, MBARI saw juvenile red crabs and Humboldt squid off Monterey Bay, and water at 60 m hit a record. What is confirmed, what scientists only expect, and why El Niño's role differs for each animal.
On September 16, an olive ridley sea turtle came ashore near Seal Beach, California, dug a nest and laid eggs. About three days later, a second turtle did the same near the Huntington Beach Pier, roughly eight miles away, according to NOAA Fisheries. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service calls these the first-ever confirmed instance of natural sea turtle nesting on the U.S. West Coast.
This piece asks one question: what can these animals tell us about the changing ocean off California? The honest answer is that each animal tells a different amount, and El Niño’s share has to be weighed separately for each.
When Hurricane Polo approached with hazardous surf and high tides, a team of biologists had to decide within 24 to 48 hours whether to move the eggs or leave them, FWS says. On September 25, they collected more than 200 eggs, 104 from Seal Beach and 100 from Huntington Beach, and took them to the Aquarium of the Pacific. After a 58-day incubation, per FWS as relayed by NBC Los Angeles, the Seal Beach eggs began to hatch. Smithsonian reports the first hatchling emerged on the evening of November 13, and about 54 had emerged from that nest roughly two hours later. Fifty Seal Beach eggs had not hatched as of the aquarium’s November 14 press conference, with viability unknown.
The Seal Beach hatchlings were released in the dark early hours of Saturday, November 14, and the Huntington Beach hatchlings early on Sunday, November 15, per the Aquarium of the Pacific and NBC Los Angeles. The aquarium says only about one in 1,000 olive ridley hatchlings reaches adulthood. We did not find an official final hatchling total in the pages we could read, so this post gives none.
A third nest, in Ventura County on November 1, was destroyed by high tides, per FWS official Jonathan Snyder as relayed secondhand by the Smithsonian.
Nobody has established it. The Aquarium of the Pacific’s own update says it is not known why the turtles chose Southern California beaches, and that the nesting may indicate an important change. FWS says the event may be partly linked to warmer ocean temperatures and El Niño conditions. Snyder told the Smithsonian that warm coastal water is certainly part of the story, and that there is another important part: decades of conservation have increased olive ridley populations, so more turtles are available to take advantage of favorable conditions. NOAA’s Justin Viezbicke has said, as quoted second hand by the Smithsonian, that the mothers may have lost their way because of a hurricane. These are candidate explanations from officials, not a finding.
MBARI’s October 29 report describes what its researchers saw on a recent expedition aboard the research vessel David Packard. Using the remotely operated vehicle Doc Ricketts, the team saw several juvenile pelagic red crabs (Grimothea planipes). MBARI says it has seen adult red crabs in Monterey Bay before but has never seen juveniles this far north. The team also caught a quick glimpse of several Humboldt squid (Dosidicus gigas). Steven Haddock’s group, diving in open water just west of Davidson Seamount, saw a winged comb jelly and a rose siphonophore, both tropical species. At MBARI’s M1 buoy, divers reported schools of halfmoon fish, a species more commonly found in Southern California.
These are all offshore, midwater or mooring observations by scientists in the Monterey Bay area. We found no 2026 report of red crabs on a California beach in the sources we read, so reports of red crabs coming ashore would be news that these sources do not confirm. Scripps’s pelagic invertebrate collection says red crabs typically occur in Southern to Central California waters during El Niño or other warm water intrusions, transported north from the waters off Baja California.
Other animals are expected, not confirmed. Scripps scientists have said they expect more tropical seabirds moving north and juvenile white sharks in high numbers, and that anchovy, tuna and dorado could stay abundant if the winter follows past patterns. Scripps describes warm-water krill and floating Janthina snails as possible warm-water signs, and its text names no 2026 sighting of either.
Scripps biological oceanographer Mark Ohman offers the most memorable detail in a published Scripps article. When he first arrived at Scripps, he says, a marine technician told him about a guano index for El Niño. If the seabird droppings on the Scripps Pier turned from white to pink to red, it meant a strong El Niño was under way, because the birds were feasting on red crabs that had come north from Baja waters. Ohman adds a caveat: not every El Niño is accompanied by red crabs.
Treat it as history. Ohman’s published recollection describes an informal historical clue, not a calibrated ENSO index or a 2026 observation. We found no dated original observation or formal validation of the guano index, and no bird species is named. Its value is as a reminder of how people read this ocean before moorings and robots: through what showed up on a pier. Today the same questions are asked with instruments. MBARI keeps a temperature time series at 60 m in Monterey Bay, which is where its record comes from, and Scripps’s marine vertebrate collection asks the public to submit photos and sightings of unusual fish through its El Niño Fish Records Form.
What these examples share is warm water. MBARI reports that the subsurface temperature at 60 m, roughly the depth of the thermocline, reached 18.18°C as of October 26, above the previous record in its time series from November 19, 1997, during an earlier El Niño. El Niño itself is well established: CPC’s November 19 discussion puts the relative Oceanic Niño Index for August to October at +2.0°C and forecasts a strong event through January to March 2027.
Where the sources are careful is timing. In an August 19 Scripps article, Simone Baumann-Pickering, a professor of biological oceanography, said NOAA scientists reported that the coastal heat wave had persisted since 2025 and was not yet caused by El Niño. On October 29, MBARI reported the first signals of an extreme El Niño reaching Monterey Bay, and senior scientist Francisco Chavez said oceanographic data and biological observations now clearly show evidence that a strong El Niño has arrived in Central California. Those statements describe different times. Together they support a regional El Niño influence this autumn on top of a heat wave already under way. They do not establish why an individual turtle nested or quantify the cause of each sighting.
| Topic | Observed | Expected, not confirmed | Still unknown |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sea turtles | Two olive ridley nests (Seal Beach, Sept 16; Huntington Beach, about Sept 19); 204 eggs relocated Sept 25; hatchlings released Nov 14 and 15; a Ventura County nest lost to tides | The aquarium says there may be more turtles that will nest or already have | Why they nested in California; whether nesting recurs; how many hatchlings survive |
| Red crabs | Several juvenile pelagic red crabs seen by MBARI’s ROV near Monterey Bay, farther north than it has seen juveniles | Red crabs typically reach Southern and Central California in warm-water intrusions | Whether they reach beaches in numbers this year; no 2026 beach report found |
| Squid and other visitors | Several Humboldt squid glimpsed; a tropical winged comb jelly and rose siphonophore; halfmoon fish schools at M1 | More tropical seabirds, juvenile white sharks, continued anchovy and tuna, per Scripps scientists | Whether any of these persist through winter |
| Ocean conditions | 60 m temperature record of 18.18°C in MBARI’s time series as of Oct 26; MBARI’s Oct 29 report of evidence that El Niño has arrived in Central California; RONI +2.0°C for Aug to Oct | El Niño’s influence expected to grow through winter 2026-27 | How much of each sighting is El Niño and how much the heat wave that began in 2025; why any individual turtle nested |
Our reading. The turtles are the clearest signal and the weakest on cause. The red crabs and squid are real but narrow observations from one study area. Taken together they fit a warm ocean in which, by MBARI’s account, El Niño has arrived. They do not apportion the cause of any single sighting, and they say nothing yet about next year.
These are checkpoints to read against this post, not a verdict on it. Whether red crabs, Humboldt squid or other warm-water species appear in more locations or persist through winter would show whether the Monterey Bay observations are local. Whether more sea turtle nests are recorded in future seasons would help show whether 2026 was a one-off or a pattern, though officials the Smithsonian quotes say they do not know which. CPC’s December 10 ENSO discussion updates El Niño’s strength and duration odds. Judging El Niño’s contribution to any one animal needs evidence across more than one season.
That has not been established. The Aquarium of the Pacific says it is not known why the turtles chose Southern California beaches. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service says the nesting may be partly linked to warmer ocean temperatures and El Niño conditions, and one of its officials said warm water is part of the story but not all of it. Other suggestions from officials include a hurricane pushing the turtles off course, and decades of conservation having increased olive ridley numbers.
In the sources we read, the confirmed 2026 red crab observation is offshore. MBARI used a remotely operated vehicle to see several juvenile pelagic red crabs in the Monterey Bay area and says it has never seen juveniles this far north. We found no 2026 beach stranding report in those sources. Scripps notes that red crabs typically reach Southern and Central California during El Niño or other warm water intrusions.
In a published Scripps article, biological oceanographer Mark Ohman recalls that a marine technician once described a guano index for El Niño: if seabird droppings on the Scripps Pier turned from white to pink to red, birds were eating red crabs that had moved north from Baja waters, which signaled a strong El Niño. It is an informal historical clue, not a calibrated ENSO index or a 2026 observation. We found no dated original observation or formal validation of it, and Ohman adds that not every El Niño brings red crabs.
Not by itself. An unusual sighting can be consistent with changing ocean conditions, but temperature measurements, currents and ecological observations are needed to interpret it. In an August 19 Scripps article, Simone Baumann-Pickering described a coastal heat wave that preceded El Niño's local influence, which NOAA scientists said had persisted since 2025 and was not yet caused by El Niño. By October 29, MBARI reported oceanographic and biological evidence that a strong El Niño had arrived in Central California. That supports a regional El Niño influence without establishing why an individual turtle nested or quantifying the cause of each sighting.